Emotions run high at the U.S. Supreme Court - WCBD-TV: News, Weather, and Sports for Charleston, SC

Emotions run high at the U.S. Supreme Court in the Fight for Baby Veronica

Posted: Updated:
Day two at SCOTUS to hear the case for baby Veronica. Day two at SCOTUS to hear the case for baby Veronica.
Dusten Brown, Veronica's biological father, and his wife walk in SCOTUS. Dusten Brown, Veronica's biological father, and his wife walk in SCOTUS.
Washington, D.C. -

The Indian Child Welfare Act was written to keep the American government from removing Native American children from a tribe and placing them in foster homes.  The idea is that it helps to preserve a struggling culture.

Emotions ran high at the United States Supreme Court Tuesday where a local family fought for custody of their adopted daughter.

It's the story News 2 has been following since New Year's Eve 2011 when the biological father left Charleston with the little girl we call baby Veronica.  News 2's Haley Hernandez is on Capitol Hill covering the story.

It's a fact that if it wasn't for ICWA Dusten Brown would not have had the legal rights to take his biological daughter Veronica back to Oklahoma to live with him.  Tuesday justices challenged both sides on whether he used the law correctly when he used it to "preserve" a Native American family where one did not previously exist.

Inside of the Supreme Court justices challenged the use of the law.  One point the justices said was deeply disturbing was that by the argument in this case, the ICWA could apply to cases where the mother didn't know the father which would happen in an instance with a sperm donor or rape.

Attorney Lisa Blatt agreed the risk is that a tribe can have ICWA on their side even if Native American parents withdraw membership or are unknown. But Terry Cross of the National Indian Child Welfare Association defends the act by saying they have never been against adoptions.

U.S. Supreme Court to hear Veronica case in less than 24 hours

Cherokee Nation release new pictures of "Baby Veronica"

Attorney: South Carolina judiciary "confused" with Baby Veronica case

We are told this law is the center of thousands of custody battles every year and that's why attorneys say the Supreme Court needs to clarify or rewrite the ICWA.  The way it legally defines a parent conflicts with how state laws say a father is either a parent through marriage or present during pregnancy. In Veronica's case Brown did not so that and that's why the American Academy of Adoption Attorneys say South Carolina was wrong to allow him to take Veronica after she was born and raised into the Charleston home.

The Cherokee nation claims this is modern discrimination against the tribe. Tuesday morning at 8 a.m. they held a prayers service at the Supreme Court.

The Attorney General of Cherokee nation says the Indian country has seen many defeats on these steps but also many victories but prays for "victory" of baby Veronica.

  • Ten year old gives aid to the homeless

    Ten year old gives aid to the homeless

    Wednesday, April 16 2014 6:48 PM EDT2014-04-16 22:48:00 GMT
    Wednesday, a ten-year-old boy hosted a food and clothing drive to help the homeless in Charleston. The drive took place at James Island Elementary. John Cromwell, a 5th grader at James Island Elementary School, wanted to do something for the homeless in the area.
    Wednesday, a ten-year-old boy hosted a food and clothing drive to help the homeless in Charleston. The drive took place at James Island Elementary. John Cromwell, a 5th grader at James Island Elementary School, wanted to do something for the homeless in the area.
  • 2 Your Health New technology keeps runners on the move

    2 Your Health New technology keeps runners on the move

    2 Your Health New technology keeps runners on the move

    Wednesday, April 16 2014 4:13 PM EDT2014-04-16 20:13:09 GMT
    There are few people who can boast running thousands of miles but Deanna Smith can.30 half marathons and 25 full marathons and dozens of running injuries.She hopes that new technology will end her running problems and keep her on the roadfor many more years.In just 48 hours, Smith will join the chorus of pounding feet during the cooper river bridge run."Running with 13 kids and we've been training for the run so i have to be ready," Smith said.The 6.2 miles is a hop and a skip for this athlet...
    There are few people who can boast running thousands of miles but Deanna Smith can.30 half marathons and 25 full marathons and dozens of running injuries.She hopes that new technology will end her running problems and keep her on the roadfor many more years.In just 48 hours, Smith will join the chorus of pounding feet during the cooper river bridge run."Running with 13 kids and we've been training for the run so i have to be ready," Smith said.The 6.2 miles is a hop and a skip for this athlet...
  • Dorchester County Sheriff says new jail needed

    Dorchester County Sheriff says new jail needed

    Wednesday, April 16 2014 3:43 PM EDT2014-04-16 19:43:43 GMT
    Dorchester County will be getting a new jail located in Summerville near the Sheriff’s office. The existing facility is in St. George. The sheriff’s office says the facility is too small and overcrowded. The Dorchester County Sheriff’s office says there are a number of security issues due to the facility being out here in St. George vs. Summerville.. Inmate transportation back and forth, the age of the facility, overcrowding of the facility present security problems. “We’re rated at over ...
    Dorchester County will be getting a new jail located in Summerville near the Sheriff’s office. The existing facility is in St. George. The sheriff’s office says the facility is too small and overcrowded. The Dorchester County Sheriff’s office says there are a number of security issues due to the facility being out here in St. George vs. Summerville.. Inmate transportation back and forth, the age of the facility, overcrowding of the facility present security problems. “We’re rated at over ...
Powered by WorldNow

210 W. Coleman Blvd.
Mt. Pleasant, SC 29464

Telephone: 843.216.4875
Fax: 843.881.3410
Email: news@wcbd.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.