Audio recording from inside baby Veronica Supreme Court hearing - WCBD-TV: News, Weather, and Sports for Charleston, SC

Audio recording from inside baby Veronica Supreme Court hearing

Posted: Updated:

Tuesday morning Supreme Court justices had to ask hypothetical, and meticulous questions about the federal statute at the heart of the fight for baby Veronica, the Indian Child Welfare Act.

In the video you hear some of the challenging questions justices presented to both legal representatives.

Chief Justice John Roberts: "As is appears, this case is he had 3 Cherokee ancestors at the time of George Washington's father. Now, you say oh well that's a different issue. But I don't see how to decide that case without thinking about this issue because if your view is taken and you accept that definition, a woman who is a rape victim who has never seen the father, could, would in fact be at risk under this statute... And you don't know that this beyond a reasonable doubt standard would satisfy that, now that's obviously something I find disturbing as a person and as a judge."

Charles Rothfeld (attorney for biological father Dusten Brown): "I am confident on an application through sect. 19-12F would lead to termination of that father's parental rights and so he would never be in the picture as a possible. Well, the question whether or not custody of someone who has engaged in such conduct would lead to serious emotional or physical damage to the chi ld I think would be no difficulty in reaching that conclusion."

Lisa Blatt (attorney for adoptive couple): This case is going to affect any interracial adoption of children.

Justice Antonin Scalia: That was its intent.

Blatt: No!

Scalia: You don't think that's what its intent was?...

Blatt: No!

Scalia: It only applies to children, to tribal children and the purpose was to establish much more difficult standards for the adoption of a tribal child.

Blatt: No, Justice Scalia.

Scalia: Now maybe you disagree with that policy but that's clearly..

Blatt: No I think the policy is fantastic! It was talking about Indian families who were being ripped away because of cultural biases and insensitivity. This case didn't involve cultural biases.

Scalia: It didn't say that. Its definition...

Blatt: There's 30,000 pages of legislative history that's talking about the removal.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg: That's what provoked the act. That Indian children were being removed from their families but the act is written in much broader terms.

Blatt: I agree! 1915 is extraordinary if you read it the way the tribe does which is, and the government does and a little bit about the membership criteria, the tribe's view is any child born Indian is automatically a member so even if the parents withdrew their tribal membership this child would be covered.

  • Investigation underway into fire at Ashley Oaks Apartments in West Ashley

    Investigation underway into fire at Ashley Oaks Apartments in West Ashley

    Monday, July 28 2014 3:55 AM EDT2014-07-28 07:55:06 GMT
    An investigation is underway into an early morning fire at Ashley Oaks Apartments in West Ashley.According to Charleston City Fire, crews from City Fire, St Andrews Fire, Charleston County EMS, and Charleston City Police Departments arrived at 12:13 Monday morning to Ashley Hall Plantation Road following reports of a structure fire.The entire building was evacuated and crews contained the fire to one unit.The fire was under control within 30 minutes.The Red Cross is being notified for displac...
    An investigation is underway into an early morning fire at Ashley Oaks Apartments in West Ashley.According to Charleston City Fire, crews from City Fire, St Andrews Fire, Charleston County EMS, and Charleston City Police Departments arrived at 12:13 Monday morning to Ashley Hall Plantation Road following reports of a structure fire.The entire building was evacuated and crews contained the fire to one unit.The fire was under control within 30 minutes.The Red Cross is being notified for displac...
  • Murder case possibly placed in jeopardy due to detective's affair with suspect's mother

    Murder case possibly placed in jeopardy due to detective's affair with suspect's mother

    Monday, July 28 2014 3:03 AM EDT2014-07-28 07:03:03 GMT
    A former Charleston County Sheriff’s office detective puts a murder case in jeopardy after it is discovered that he slept with a murder suspect’s mother. The trial of defendant Reginald Gordon was set to begin on July 28 but may have been delayed due to a motion to dismiss filed by the defense attorney. It was discovered that detective Charles Lawrence was sleeping with the mother of Gordon’s co-defendant Derrick Brow...
    A former Charleston County Sheriff’s office detective puts a murder case in jeopardy after it is discovered that he slept with a murder suspect’s mother. The trial of defendant Reginald Gordon was set to begin on July 28 but may have been delayed due to a motion to dismiss filed by the defense attorney. It was discovered that detective Charles Lawrence was sleeping with the mother of Gordon’s co-defendant Derrick Brow...
  • Nightclub owner accused of killing patron

    Nightclub owner accused of killing patron

    Nightclub owner accused of killing patron

    Sunday, July 27 2014 8:11 PM EDT2014-07-28 00:11:12 GMT
    ORANGEBURG, S.C. (AP) - A retired New York corrections officer is accused of killing a man at the Orangeburg nightclub he owned. The Times and Democrat of Orangeburg reports (http://bit.ly/1uvFMjn ) 69-year-old James Williams was charged Saturday with murder in the July 19 death of 26-year-old Phillip Brunson at the Corner Pocket Club. According to an incident report, Williams told deputies Brunson tried to enter his club with a pistol, and when Brunson shot at a glass door, Williams returned...
    ORANGEBURG, S.C. (AP) - A retired New York corrections officer is accused of killing a man at the Orangeburg nightclub he owned. The Times and Democrat of Orangeburg reports (http://bit.ly/1uvFMjn ) 69-year-old James Williams was charged Saturday with murder in the July 19 death of 26-year-old Phillip Brunson at the Corner Pocket Club. According to an incident report, Williams told deputies Brunson tried to enter his club with a pistol, and when Brunson shot at a glass door, Williams returned...
Powered by WorldNow

210 W. Coleman Blvd.
Mt. Pleasant, SC 29464

Telephone: 843.216.4875
Fax: 843.881.3410
Email: news@wcbd.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.