Bill would limit trespasser lawsuits against homeowners, landown - WCBD-TV: News, Weather, and Sports for Charleston, SC

Bill would limit trespasser lawsuits against homeowners, landowners in SC

Posted: Updated:
Spartanburg attorney Gary Poliakoff argues against a trespassing bill Thursday at the Statehouse. Spartanburg attorney Gary Poliakoff argues against a trespassing bill Thursday at the Statehouse.
A bill now making its way through the South Carolina Senate would limit homeowners’ or landowners’ liability if a trespasser on their property gets hurt. Attorney Will Johnson says previous cases in the state show the need for the law.

"A drunk driver of a motorcycle was trespassing on a landowner's property; drove his motorcycle up an embankment. The motorcycle rolled over and led to serious problems. In that case, there was a lawsuit against the landowner,” he says.

In another case, a group of boys was walking on property owned by International Paper in Georgetown County. There was a canal on the land, with a pipe that went out into the water. The boys walked out onto the pipe. One of the boys, only 10 years old, fell into the water and drowned. His family sued for wrongful death.

While those cases illustrate why some lawyers say the bill is needed, there was no specific case that prompted Sen. Larry Martin, R-Pickens, to sponsor it. What prompted the bill was a new “Restatement of the Law,” a series of legal papers by scholars that’s put out by the American Law Institute. Judges can use them to make rulings.

Johnson says the latest Restatement of the Law expands the duties of property owners to potential trespassers, which goes against South Carolina’s common law. He says if lawmakers don’t pass this bill, it would likely mean a lot more lawsuits against homeowners and property owners, which in turn would drive up liability insurance prices for everyone.

Sen. Martin says if his bill passes, "The landowner would be assured that if a trespasser, or an uninvited person, is on their property and they fall and get hurt or in some way injure themselves, they're not liable."

But Spartanburg attorney Gary Poliakoff says, "There simply is no need to do this, and in doing it we upend this 150 years of well-reasoned case law."

He says the way the bill is worded, some protections for children would be eliminated.

A Senate subcommittee worked on the bill Thursday morning, deciding to look into the case law and possibly amend the bill. No vote was taken.

  • Charleston city planners discuss Upper Peninsula developments

    Charleston city planners discuss Upper Peninsula developments

    Thursday, July 31 2014 11:41 PM EDT2014-08-01 03:41:40 GMT
    Tonight in downtown Charleston a public meeting was held to discuss large-scale developments for the city's Upper Peninsula area.
    Tonight in downtown Charleston a public meeting was held to discuss large-scale developments for the city's Upper Peninsula area.
  • SC will not ignore Common core when writing new school standards

    SC will not ignore Common core when writing new school standards

    Thursday, July 31 2014 10:47 PM EDT2014-08-01 02:47:09 GMT
    A dispute over how to rewrite South Carolina's math and reading standards pits leaders of South Carolina's two education boards against Education Superintendent Mick Zais, three months before voters replace him. Zais has promised to use a new law to kill Common Core standards before he leaves office in January. The one-term Republican lacks the authority to do so. But he has influence over the review process. The law directs educator panels to review current math and reading standards, which ...
    A dispute over how to rewrite South Carolina's math and reading standards pits leaders of South Carolina's two education boards against Education Superintendent Mick Zais, three months before voters replace him. Zais has promised to use a new law to kill Common Core standards before he leaves office in January. The one-term Republican lacks the authority to do so. But he has influence over the review process. The law directs educator panels to review current math and reading standards, which ...
  • Tigers report for preseason practice

    Tigers report for preseason practice

    Thursday, July 31 2014 8:04 PM EDT2014-08-01 00:04:41 GMT
    Clemson, S.C.—Dabo Swinney welcomed 105 active Clemson football players to the first official team meeting of the preseason on Thursday at 4:00 p.m. Swinney’s sixth Clemson squad met for nearly four hours with various department leaders of the program who gave orientation instructions to their specific areas.The day started with the announcement that Clemson was ranked 16th in the preseas...
    Clemson, S.C.—Dabo Swinney welcomed 105 active Clemson football players to the first official team meeting of the preseason on Thursday at 4:00 p.m. Swinney’s sixth Clemson squad met for nearly four hours with various department leaders of the program who gave orientation instructions to their specific areas.The day started with the announcement that Clemson was ranked 16th in the preseas...
Powered by WorldNow

210 W. Coleman Blvd.
Mt. Pleasant, SC 29464

Telephone: 843.216.4875
Fax: 843.881.3410
Email: news@wcbd.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.